Fight ‘Em ‘Til We Can’t

A Montana criminal defense blog.

?>

Caseloads and Burnout

Filed under:PD System — posted by tc on December 13, 2006 @ 7:22 am

New public defender, Frolics and Detours (she doesn’t work in Montana; I’m not sure where she is), just started a couple of months ago and already has a massive caseload of 189 cases. Not surprisingly, she’s already feeling a little burned out:

I’m so exhausted. As a new attorney with a huge case load, it’s hard to determine when it is time to stop working and go home. Once I get home, I just crash. But then I wake up in the middle of the night and my mind starts racing. Aside from getting on meds, any suggestions for a newbie to help me feel better and not get so overwhelmed?

She’s received some good advice in response: do triage daily, focus on the big things and what must be done now, postpone what can wait. Of course, for a newbie, figuring out what is and is not crucial may be the hardest part. Blonde Justice also recommends less caffeine. I’ll just be taking that one under advisement.

Here in Montana, the Public Defender Commission has promulgated caseload standards to help reduce the chance of burnout and also to ensure that attorneys are not so overworked that their clients do not get good representation. Chapter II, section V of those standards says caseload should not exceed the following:

  1. 150 Felony cases (excluding those in which the death penalt y is being sought) per attorney per year; or,
  2. 300 Misdemeanor Cases per attorney per year; or,
  3. 250 Misdemeanor Juvenile Offender Cases per attorney per year; or,
  4. 60 Juvenile Dependency Clients per attorney per year; or,
  5. 100 Civil Commit ment Cases per attorney per year; or,
  6. 25 Appeals to the Montana Supreme Court per attorney per year; or,
  7. 25 post­convict ion matters per attorney per year; or,
  8. 12 petitions for certiorari to the United State Supreme Court per attorney per year.

I don’t know how it is around the state, but I’m pretty sure the majority of public defenders have already met—or have come pretty close to meeting—their yearly “quotas” in the five months since the system started on July 1. [tags]caseload, burnout, standards[/tags]

comments (0)

Determining indegency

Filed under:Comment,Opinions,PD System — posted by tc on October 16, 2006 @ 6:27 am

Who decides whether a defendant qualifies as “indigent” for purposes of being appointed a public defender under Montana’s new Public Defender Act? That was the question the MT Supreme Court recently decided in Rios v. Harris. In brief, the Court granted a Writ of Supervisory Control saying that the Office of State Public Defender (OSPD) decides who qualifies according to the criteria specified in Title 47 of the Montana Code.

The Court said that §47-1-111(1), MCA, calls for appointment of counsel as follows:

  1. The court appoints counsel to any accused person facing jail time (and also in dependent/neglect and a few other matters). See also §47-1-104(4), MCA.
  2. The Office of State Public Defender (OSPD) begins representation but also determines whether the defendant meets the indigency criteria.
  3. If the defendant is not eligible, the OSPD must notify the court so that the court may rescind its order appointing counsel. However, OSPD must remain as counsel until the court issues such an order.
  4. The court may review the OSPD’s determination of eligibility, but only in cases where one of the parties requests such review. Under no circumstances my a court initiate such a review sua sponte.

Justice Jim Rice dissented, claiming that the majority erred in holding that a court cannot initiate the indigency determination on its own.

Does anyone have any thoughts on this opinion? Did the majority get it right or was Rice more on target? And how common is it for the Court to issue a Writ of Supervisory Control?

comments (3)

previous page

  • Crimlaw Newsbits:
    • Woman finds 'Goldilocks' snoring in her son's bed:

      Judge Susan Watters set bail at $5,000 after rejecting a request that he be released without bail. Public defender Richard Phillips, who made the request, said Mullins had been receiving mental-health counseling. @.

      - #

    • Bail set for youth held in Huntley arson:

      Sampson argued that the high bond sought by prosecutors was “disproportionate” to the allegations and “simply more fuel to the emotional fire.” She asked the judge to consider releasing Victoria to the custody of his parents, who attended the hearing, or an aunt who lives in Billings. @.

      - #

    • Montana mom kept dead son in car trunk:

      The body of a toddler found in the trunk of his mother’s car may have been there for months as she drove around town, evaded questions about him and was even arrested, police said. @

      - #

    • Trail rapist resentenced to life:

      Stearns was represented in court by public defender Carl Jensen, who tried to persuade McKittrick not to impose a life sentence because Stearns is appealing his Ravalli County conviction to the Montana Supreme Court. ⇒

      - #

    • Ex-defender in Hudson now judge:

      NJ: The former head of the Hudson County Public Defender's Office was expected to be sworn in last night as an Essex County Superior Court judge in a ceremony in Newark. ⇒ Crazy. I can't see anything like this ever happening here...

      - #

  • Archives:
    • December 2009
    • July 2009
    • September 2008
    • August 2008
    • April 2008
    • March 2008
    • February 2008
    • January 2008
    • December 2007
    • October 2007
    • September 2007
    • August 2007
    • July 2007
    • June 2007
    • May 2007
    • April 2007
    • March 2007
    • February 2007
    • January 2007
    • December 2006
    • November 2006
    • October 2006
  • Categories:
    • Admin
    • Books
    • Comment
    • Cops
    • Discretion
    • District Court
    • DUI
    • Homicide
    • Investigation
    • Judges
    • Juries
    • Meta
    • Misdemeanor Practice
    • Motions
    • NewsBits
    • Opinions
    • PD News
    • PD System
    • Pretrial
    • Prisons
    • Probation
    • Profession
    • Prosecutors
    • Search & Seizure
    • Sentencing
    • Trial
    • Uncategorized
  • links:
    • Defense Investigators

      • Busted Guitar Strings
      • PD Investigator Network
      • Public Defender Investigator
    • MT Crimlaw Resources

      • Connections Corrections
      • Daubert on the Web
      • District Court Rules
      • HIRE Network
      • Montana Code
      • Montana Courts
      • Montana Law Week
      • Montana Public Defender Blog
      • MT Crime Stats
      • MT DOC daily population
      • MTACDL
      • State Law Library Blog
    • Other Crimlaw Blogs

      • Indefensible
      • PrisonSucks.com
    • Public Defender Blogs

      • Arbitrary and Capricious
      • Audacity
      • Blonde Justice
      • Defending Those People
      • Gideon’s Guardians
      • Injustice Anywhere
      • PD Blog Guide
      • Public Pretender
      • Woman of the Law
      • Wretched of the Earth

  • Disclaimer:
    • Nothing expressed here should be considered legal advice. If you need legal advice, please contact a lawyer in person -- not via this blog. All opinions expressed here are those of their authors and do not represent the opinions of the authors' employers or anyone else.
  • Meta:
    • Log in
    • feed:RSS or RSS
    • Comments feed:RSS or RSS
    • WP

Powered by WordPress
and the artsemerging theme
by nathaniel stern

image: detail of installation by Bronwyn Lace